General Health & Wellness • Aug 03, 2010

Should your child be vaccinated?

Although the members of our team do not work in primary care settings and thus do not routinely give vaccines as part of our practice, it still has an effect on what we see and do in the hospital setting. 

As physicians, our goal and our job is not just to treat those who are ill, but also to educate as much as possible in order to stay well and prevent disease.  I know that those who oppose vaccines will most likely not change their minds from what I write here, but I do want everyone who reads this to become informed and learn about what is true and not true in regards to vaccines.  While we as physicians always advocate for what we think is best, it is ultimately YOUR decision to make about what is done with regard to your child.  So let’s try and make that decision as informed as possible.

Vaccinations are one of the greatest inventions in the history of mankind.  As a result of how amazingly effective and powerful they have been, their success has also caused them to be questioned in recent years.  Why is that?  Because many of the diseases parents, children, and medical care givers used to see on a regular basis simply are no longer seen.  It is this “out of sight, out of mind” phenomenon that has many parents questioning whether vaccines are necessary and worth it.  The bottom line is that giving vaccines, like everything else we do in our lives, is about risk and benefit.  Do the benefits outweigh the risks?  Am I doing the right thing for my child?  When that question is asked of vaccines, the overwhelming answer is YES.  The benefits greatly outweigh the risks.  Here are some numbers to help visualize this.

1.  Pertussis, or “whooping cough”, affected almost 30,000 people in the US from 1997-2000.  In 2004, there were over 25,000 cases reported, the most since 1959.  Infants under 6 months of age are most at risk of contracting the disease and two-thirds of them will require hospitalization. 

2.  Measles is extremely dangerous and contagious.  Between 1989-1991, a U.S. measles outbreak affected 55,000 people and resulted in 132 deaths.  Worldwide, about 500,000 children die each year from measles.

3.  Between 1988-1995, almost 10,000 people suffered complications from chicken pox that required hospitalization.  An average of 43 children died every year from 1990-1994. 

4.  There were more than 150 deaths in children related to influenza (flu) between 2003-2004. 
These are just some examples.  While some of these numbers may seem insignificant because of how low they are, each one is absolutely significant because they were mostly preventable.  In addition to this, when compared to the safety numbers for vaccines, those stats are simply unacceptable.

There are various reasons why parents choose not to vaccinate their children.  Here are some of them:

1.  “These diseases are so rare and everyone else has their children immunized that mine simply doesn’t need it”.  The issue with this idea is that while the incidence of these diseases has definitely decreased as a result of widespread vaccinations, they still exist.  One of the greatest risks comes as a result of travel from other countries.  With the ease of air travel in today’s world, it only takes ONE person to start an epidemic.  Only one person with polio.  Only one person with measles.  As has already happened, those children who are not immunized are at greatest risk.  In addition to this, as more and more children remain unvaccinated, the coverage provided by “herd immunity” decreases.  While it’s unclear exactly where the breaking point is (estimated to be between 85-90%), it’s not something we should be willing to find out.

2.  “I’ll just wait or spread them out so that my baby isn’t exposed to too much too early and all at once”.  Again, there are a few issues with the above.  First, it is young infants who are most at risk to catch many of the vaccine-covered illnesses and suffer more severe complications.  The longer vaccines are delayed, the more risk is being placed on a child by potentially exposing them to dangerous but preventable illnesses.  Secondly, the antigen load placed on children by vaccines is a fraction of what the body is able to handle and process.  In fact, as vaccines have been improved, the total number of antigens by all vaccines combined is lower than the number of antigens that were present in the single original polio vaccine!  While it may seem that children are being given more and more, the efficiency with how these newer vaccines are designed and delivered is actually lowering the antigenic load.  Finally, there has been a smaller study that has shown that infants who were vaccinated earlier on had fewer overall infections when compared to those that were not immunized or were delayed.

3.  “How do I know the vaccines are safe?”  A common question is about the Rotavirus vaccine that was associated with a rare but serious complication called intussusception.  Out of one million children who were vaccinated with the original rotavirus vaccine, 100 children developed intussusception (or 1 out of 10,000 children).  Because the initial studies done for the vaccine involved 11,000 children, this is the reason why this rare complication was not originally noticed.  Despite the fact that this incidence is similar to the overall incidence of intussusception in unvaccinated children, the original Rotavirus vaccine was removed until a safer vaccine was developed.  The newer vaccines (Rotateq and Rotarix) have not been shown to be associated with intussusception at this point in time and are considered very safe.  Of note, despite the possible association of intussusception with the initial rotavirus vaccine, more than 16,000 children who were not immunized were hospitalized for dehydration and 5-10 of them died as a result.  The risk of not immunizing still remained.

4.  “I do not want to risk my child developing autism”.  I have little doubt that everyone reading this article has heard of numerous stories linking autism with vaccines.  This has become probably the largest obstacle to vaccinations that pediatricians face today.  Part of the reason for this is the widespread media attention that this has garnered.   Unfortunately, the misinformation provided to parents trying to do their “research” can make the issue terribly confusing and difficult to process.  I will simply state that there has not been a single peer-reviewed, well-controlled study that has shown any link between autism and vaccines.  Not a single one.  The original claim has never been replicated.  In fact, Dr. Wakefield, the person who started the scare between the MMR vaccine and autism was found to have fixed and altered the results in his study!!  Unfortunately, the results of his small, fraudulent study involving 20 children have had a long-lasting negative effect on vaccinations.  Because of this, the link between autism and vaccines has been studied extensively across the world by a large amount of independent researchers and the link simply is not there.  If there was, the MMR vaccine would have been removed much like the rotavirus one was recently.  While we still do not have an answer as to what causes or triggers autism, we do know one thing that does not—Vaccines!! 

There is a wealth of information regarding vaccinations, both good and bad.  Trying to weed through it without guidance can be tedious and confusing.  Please visit our website for links to accurate and up-to-date information regarding vaccinations, their benefits, and their risks or consult with your pediatrician to make an informed decision as to whether to vaccinate your child.